Shane McMahon resigns from WWE–could MMA be in his future?

By Jim Murphy October 16th, 2009

The big news today is that Shane McMahon–son of Vince McMahon–has resigned from the WWE. Here’s his statement from the WWE website and then we’ll tell you what this all means for you, the MMA fan:

It is with great sadness that I announce my resignation from the WWE, effective January 1, 2010.

I have never even considered a future outside the walls of the WWE. However, sometimes life takes an unexpected turn and while it is the most difficult decision I have ever made, it is time for me to move on.

First and foremost, I would like to thank my father for the incredible education working with him has provided and for giving me the opportunity to play a role in building WWE into the global phenomenon that it is today. I am extremely proud to have been the 4th generation in this business, and I am grateful for everyday I was able to work along side not only my own, but the entire WWE family.

Thank you to all of the WWE Superstars both past and present for your passion, pride and dedication. You are truly the engine of the organization and it has been a pleasure to work with, learn from and get to know all of you. Thank you for the privilege of sharing the stage with you and for allowing me to become but a momentary member of your elite brotherhood. I have so much appreciation for the many sacrifices you endure, both physically and personally, to make this business the success that it is. The respect I have for each of you is immeasurable.

Finally, there are no words to express my gratitude to WWE fans the world over for supporting this company through good times and bad and for your unbridled passion that fuels the Superstars’ performances. I am profoundly grateful to have been able to entertain you both in front of the camera and from behind the scenes. You are the greatest fans in the world.

I will always love this business and will remain a fan forever.

Shane McMahon resigns at WWE.com

Shane is sharp as a tack, and is well known as the big MMA fan within the WWE operations. Before the UFC finally bought (and bungled the purchase of) PRIDE FC in 2007, Shane attempted to broker a deal for the WWE to buy them out and get into the MMA business. Reportedly, his dad (that would be Vince McMahon) isn’t sold on the longterm viability of MMA and views it as something of a ‘fad’. Vinny Mac also has questions about a business that is promoted the same way as pro wrestling but that you can’t ‘work’ to make sure fight outcomes go the way you want them to.

Anyway, Shane has remained a MMA fan and has been known to have misgivings about the direction the WWE product is going in. More specifically, he doesn’t like the move to a product more geared for the ‘18 and younger’ demographic and is a fan of more stiff, realistic wrestling and actual fighting. He’s young, rich, has worked around the wrestling business since he was a kid and is a sharp guy with great contacts.

So here’s my hunch–and its just a hunch at this point: he’s going to get into the MMA business in some capacity. Clearly, he won’t go to work for TNA or ROH–if he wanted to have a role building a smaller wrestling promotion he would have been able to facilitate that within the WWE. Plus, he’s still a major WWE stockholder and I’m sure he’s not going to do anything that would directly compete with the company his family built.

Vince McMahon did an interview earlier this week that has been lampooned by many of the more thin skinned types within the MMA fan and media base where he called the WWE ‘a more sophisticated product’ than the UFC/MMA. My take is that this was misconstrued by the people who got their panties in a wad, and what he meant is that from a business standpoint promoting pro wrestling is more nuanced and multifaceted than promoting ’shoot’ fights and you can make a good case that this is true. The more interesting component relative to today’s announcement by Shane O’Mac is that he went out of his way to clarify that he didn’t view MMA as competition for the WWE product and that the two had different fanbases.

With the Ultimate Fighting Championship and mixed martial arts becoming more popular as competitors, it made little sense for the WWE to ramp up the attitude with violence and sexuality, McMahon said.

“You really can’t compete with that,” he said. “Why not deliver a more sophisticated product and not go to those extremes? If the audience wants those extremes, they know where to go and how to get it.”

Going PG has helped the company draw advertisers who might have looked away before. Pepsi, 7-Eleven stores, Mattel toys and the Army National Guard are among the sponsors that have signed up since the shift, the company said.

Vinny Mac has said similar things in the past and by and large I disagree with much of his take on the demographics–you can make a good case (and Dave Meltzer at The Wrestling Observer has done that) that the UFC/MMA has really sucked away much of the adult fan base of pro wrestling. That’s as much at the root of the WWE ‘going PG’ as advertisers and cleaning up the product for Linda McMahon’s Senate campaign. Instead of chasing a fanbase that was flocking to MMA, why not go after the fans that were still there? Still, the timing could be seen as dad giving his ‘blessings’ to son’s future career path.

Some have speculated that McMahon could go to work for the UFC, but that’s very unlikely. What is more likely is that he’ll choose to compete with the UFC in some fashion–either by creating his own promotion or going to work for a competitor. When you’ve been in the situation he’s been in all his life–where the name on the big office has alternately been his grandfather, father or mother–becoming just another employee who’d be well down the chain of command from the Fertittas and Dana White, if not others, just doesn’t have its appeal. Taking f-bomb laden orders from The Dana may be a dream job for ‘Zuffa Zombies’ but not for a guy who has been in McMahon’s position. He’s definitely not going to go to work for a guy who has been called by many as the next Vince McMahon–Dana’s not, for a number of reasons but Google ‘Vince McMahon Dana White’ and you’ll see what I’m talking about.

Now, Shane could sidestep all of this and become a film producer or televangelist, but that’s hard to see. Here’s my educated guess having followed Shane’s career from when he first appeared on WWE TV–he’ll be in the MMA business in some capacity. Here’s my wildcard scenario: he’ll become the public face and a top executive of STRIKEFORCE, and perhaps take an ownership interest. Strikeforce is even less of a competitor to his family’s business than the UFC since they’re not in the PPV business at the moment. He’s knowledgable of Japanese MMA and no doubt sees a lot of potential in the promotion’s working relationship with DREAM and understands that they’ve got a lot of talent already in the fold. Most importantly, he could see the value of their TV relationships with CBS and Showtime. And lest we forget, Shane’s primary role in the WWE was ‘Executive Vice President of WWE Global Media’ responsible for among other things “International Television Distribution, Live Event bookings, Digital Media, Consumer products, and Publishing”. Unlike his sister Stephanie, who has routinely been criticized her handling of the creative end of the product, Shane has received high marks from everyone for his work in his gig. He’s got the contacts and smarts to potentially take an existing company to the next level, perhaps making Strikeforce the circa late 1990’s WCW to the UFC’s WWE.

Of course, he could just start a company from scratch but that seems unlikely for a number of reasons, not the least of which would be his experience with the WWE. He’d have to attract talent, build a brand, secure TV deals, get PPV clearances, worry about building revenue, so on and so forth. My hunch–and again, its only a hunch–is that he’s much more interested in taking an established product to ‘the next level’. He could end up being a Dana White toady, but don’t be surprised if he becomes part of Team Strikeforce early next year after he officially leaves the WWE. From a lot of perspectives, its the best fit and most compelling challenge for him.

7 Responses to “Shane McMahon resigns from WWE–could MMA be in his future?”

  1. Fred Says:

    Interesting. I thought long ago (after the PRIDE bid) that Vince himself might step up and buy (or invest) in Strikeforce. Let’s see where this storyline goes.

  2. Jim Says:

    By all accounts Vince has little interest in MMA personally or professionally. Shane was always the advocate for MMA within the WWE and I can’t really see him leaving such a cushy gig unless he’s got something in the works. He’s expressed interest in film production at various points, but with the experience and contacts from his role within the WWE it sure looks like a perfect fit for Strikeforce. I just don’t see him leaving the ‘family business’ to become an employee of Zuffa or anyone else. My thinking is that he’s going to have an equity stake in something.

  3. Jim Murphy Says:

    We’ll get that corrected posthaste and we certainly regret the error

  4. Mark Says:

    Although I consider myself a major WWE fan I can only hope that Vince or any McMahon stays out of the MMA game. I am also a fan of all aspects of MMA and I truly belive that Vince would more than likely hurt the sport than help it. I think this is true for 1 reason. When Vince attempted to start a pro football league called the XFL he could not help but destroy it by smothering it with WWE colors and publicity. The Rock, Vince McMahon, Jim Ross, Mick Foley and Jonathan Coachman were just a few of the WWE personalities shoved down are throats with the XFL. It’s kind of like type-casting. Any time WWE stars get involved with anything other than wrestling, all believability goes out the window. The moment that happened potential fans said, “I’m not here to watch wrestling”, and they tuned out. The moment you introduce the ideals of pro wrestling into any sport you automatically alienate yourself. The fact is that although I am a fan of both WWE and UFC, my appreciation for them have nothing to do with the other. I watch them both for completely different reasons and would not want them mixed in anyway. I think that if a McMahon became a majority stakeholder in the UFC or MMA in general there would be great backlash. There is also an underground distain from MMA fighters and hardcore fans toward pro wrestlers. In no way do they want to be associated. I don’t think it is due to a lack of respect but it is obvious that in no way would they even want to be considered a similar sport. In no way do I doubt the genius of any McMahon, but just because one may excel in one area that doesn’t mean they can do it all. In the famous words of the The Rock, “Know your role!”

  5. Jim Murphy Says:

    Thanks for the comment–this is my hunch about the whole thing based on following the WWE, pro wrestling and MMA for years. Actually, I follow more of the business aspect of the WWE now than the ‘creative’ end of the product but you’re well aware that Vince McMahon has decreed that the product is to become more ‘kid friendly’. My hunch is that Shane left because he didn’t like the direction the in-ring product was heading and maybe because of that or not he decided that the timing was right to get into the MMA game.

    While I agree that there’s not much value to either party in using Shane in a major ‘on camera’ role (like the UFC does with Dana White, for example) I think he’d be a great asset to any MMA promotion due to his experience in his ‘off camera’ role in the WWE–basically he dealt with logistical issues, opened foreign markets and dealt with other marketing related elements of the business. Unlike his sister Stephanie (who has plenty of detractors) Shane was considered nothing short of extremely effective in his role. He’s got a ton of money via his WWE stock ownership, so my thinking is that he’ll end up as an investor in an existing promotion or (less likely) start his own. And unlike many investors, he’s got a lot of practical talent to help the business that he can bring to the table.

  6. Benny Says:

    If McMahon does invest in StrikeForce then Bill Goldberg will leave them (StrikeForce) because he left the WWE because he wanted to be a role model to the younger part who watch the show. And he couldn’t do that much whenever he was being a heal(the bad guy). I am 15 years old and have grown up around wrestling. At the moment I am refereeing for Southern West Virginia’s Championship Wrestling.
    If you have any questions to ask me then contact me at igootapwr@hotmail.com
    myspace.com/bennyconley
    bebo.com/benifulxd

  7. Jim Murphy Says:

    I don’t think that Bill Goldberg is really involved with Strikeforce. He did commentary on some Elite XC shows and *may* have done some similar work for Strikeforce, but if he has he hasn’t done so in quite a while. In any case, good luck with your wrestling career!

Leave a Comment: